Skip to main content

Thoughts on Treasure Planet

This post is written in part to fulfill my promise to Maya that I would watch Treasure Planet before she graduated.


It was either this or Dead Poet's Society.



I thought I had seen this movie before, but it must have been too long ago because a lot of it seemed unfamiliar (not too unfamiliar as I've read Treasure Island, seen the live action Disney movie, and Muppet Treasure Island). Here are a few things that I thought about it:

  • It's very artistic. The mix of traditional and CGI is well done (not as jarring as Fox's Titan AE from two years previous)
  • This movie is fantasy, not science fiction. So, I'm not going to say "Space doesn't work that way!" except for one comment. Solar sails don't work that way! Solar sailing is a fascinating process, but it relies on the pressure of photons. It leads to very slow acceleration over a long period of time. The surface area of the sails needs to be much bigger than that depicted.
  • Every species seems unique. I would have expected to see at least a few other humans around, or dogs, or cats, or whatever Long John Silver is. But we don't. It doesn't seem to matter too much, since species can reproduce together, for whatever reason.
    Some sort of strange dog/cat alien babies.

  • I'm sad that it is not a musical. Musicals are very important to me.
  • Jim starts the movie as a teen in trouble. I don't understand juvenile delinquency. Maybe it's because I'm too much of a rule follower, but I can't imagine myself living in such a way to constantly be getting into trouble.
  • Long John Silver's betrayal of Jim is made even more painful by the fact that he became a substitute father figure. Of course, I think Chesterton points out somewhere that in order to be a betrayer, you first have to be a friend.
  • I really don't like how Jim lets Silver go at the end. He is a murderer! We might not see it on screen, but his crew is concerned that he's "gone soft" by not killing Jim. That means that he's done it before. One good act can put him on a path to redemption, but does not forgive past crimes.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My Issues with Harry Potter: Part 4 - The Education System

Okay, maybe it's because I'm not British, but the education system in the Wizarding world makes very little sense to me (a teacher). Granted, the American system doesn't make sense to much of the rest of the world. Here in the US, we don't have college entrance exams, so I won't criticize things like OWLs or NEWTs. However, I am going to have to criticize the entire theory of education. Primary Schooling A Hogwarts letter arrives on a student's 11th birthday (sort of). What are the options for students before they are 11? Rowling says that they may either go to public schools or they are home schooled. It sure seems like most magical parents choose the latter option (most wizards know nothing of the Muggle world, which should not be the case if they attended public school for 6 years). Here we run into our first problem. What exactly are these children being taught? In the US (and from what I can tell, the UK), parents are not required to fol...
Post a Comment
Read more

Gentlemen and Ladies

So, I was listening to the announcements at the end of the school day yesterday. It mentioned something about the Lady Eagles volleyball team playing the Panthers (or some such team). Why does it need to be the "Lady Eagles"? The volleyball team is exclusively women. We don't say the "Gentleman Eagles" football team. We say Savio baseball, not Savio Boy's baseball. A gentleman eagle I can see some cases where a distinction might need to be drawn between teams (soccer, swimming, track, etc). However, we should then use both modifiers (Gentlemen and Ladies). I know that the problem is bigger than just Savio. It often bothered me while I was at UT as well. Many of my students accuse me of overthinking things like this. I think that as a society, we don't consider them enough. What is the micro-message of this disparity? That male sports are "normal"? That you need to be warned that you're going to see women play sports? This is symptom...
Post a Comment
Read more

Don't Take Candy from Babies

 It's been 8 years since my last Halloween post , so I guess it's time to update my complaint. To sum up: trick-or-treating is for children. If you're not a child, buy your own candy. To be clear, I'm not anti-fun and I'm not anti costume. Case in point: What I am against is co-opting something that is meant for children and taking it for adults/teens (Disney adults is a gray area. It's okay to like Disney, but taking up all the space in the lines at the parks is rude). For the record, I am also against: Adults sitting in costumed Santa laps Adult Easter egg hunts Adults playing on playgrounds during the day while children wait for their turn on the swings with tears in their eyes (most of these scenarios involve crying children in my imagination). I think Halloween is a great time for celebration. It's the nature of the celebrations that change. For my 40th birthday, did I rent a bounce house? No, I rented a movie theater and we watched Stardust. Is Christm...
Post a Comment
Read more